Question

[wyvern]

Is there a difference between a marshalling yard and sorting sidings?

[Flying Pig]

As far as I can remember there isn't a Rulebook definition which sets them apart. Railway nomenclature varies very much with region and era. Whenever a question like this comes up there tends to be a multitude of answers, many of which appear to contradict each other but are actually correct in their own context.

Are you talking about the present, or do you have a specific time/place in mind ?

(My particular interest is Bricklayers Arms depot, which had Willow Walk sorting sidings associated with it. They certainly marshalled freight and passenger trains there, but never referred to it as a marshalling yard. )

[21Aman]

Originally Posted by wyvern

Is there a difference between a marshalling yard and sorting sidings?

I think that a marshalling yard had a "hump" for gravity shunting whereas a sorting siding(s) were used to remarshal trains on the "flat".